Famous Thin Crust Pizza Since 1935: For decades, Colony Grill has been known for a single menu item: a one-of-a-kind, Thin-Crust "Bar Pie, complete with chewy dough, an irresistibly crisp crust, and cheese that extends all the way to the edge. Simple and classic, each pizza—served with or without the signature Hot Oil topping—a Serrano pepper–infused olive oil—is best enjoyed with a cold drink, family and friends gathered around, and a stack of napkins nearby.